I
Intro: You might assume your listing agent can negotiate every term of your home sale, including the commission requested by the buyer’s agent. But what if I told you that—legally and ethically—most agents can’t negotiate that for you?
In fact, doing so might violate ethical rules, state law, or even risk a lawsuit. Here’s what sellers need to know about the limitations of traditional agents, and how working with a broker-attorney can change the game.
Section 1: The Hidden Contract Most Sellers Never See
When a buyer signs a Buyer Representation and Broker Compensation (BRBC) agreement, they’re agreeing to pay their agent—often 2.5% to 3% of the purchase price.
But here’s the twist: many buyers expect you, the seller, to cover that cost through your proceeds.
And your agent? They’re not part of that contract.
Section 2: Why Listing Agents Can’t Negotiate It
Listing agents are not parties to the BRBC. That means:
- They cannot ethically interfere with it.
- They are not trained or licensed to interpret third-party contracts.
- They have no CAR forms authorizing them to negotiate buyer agent compensation on your behalf.
In fact, California Association of Realtors (CAR) removed forms that once allowed agents to discuss buyer-side commission—likely due to legal risk and regulatory scrutiny.
Section 3: What Can Go Wrong if They Try?
If your listing agent calls the buyer’s agent and tries to “negotiate” their 3% commission request down to 1% without proper authority, it could:
- Violate the REALTOR® Code of Ethics (Standard of Practice 16-16).
- Trigger lawsuits from the buyer agent for tortious interference or unpaid commissions.
- Expose you, the seller, to liability if it appears you were involved.
Section 4: What an Attorney-Broker Can Do Instead
Unlike a traditional agent, a licensed attorney-broker can:
- Interpret the BRBC and related third-party agreements.
- Negotiate buyer agent compensation on your behalf with your written consent.
- Draft custom language and authorizations that protect you while increasing your net.
- Use a structured offer review process to legally factor buyer agent commission into the negotiation—without violating state law or REALTOR® rules.
Section 5: The Million-Dollar Shift Happening Now
Because of DOJ lawsuits and policy changes, most listing agents have been stripped of the tools they once used to create multiple offers and strong outcomes.
- They can’t offer buyer agent comp directly in the MLS.
- They can’t negotiate buyer comp without stepping outside their license.
- They are stuck being passive, even when thousands of dollars are on the table.
But sellers aren’t powerless—if they use the right strategy.
CTA: Want to See How the Right Process Can Increase Your Net?
Download the forms, watch the training, and join the Q&A at:
Get the protection and strategy you need—before you list your home.
Coming Next: Part 2: “How the Right Counteroffer Strategy Can Turn a 3% Commission Into a 1% Win Without Losing the Deal”
Recent Comments